Here's my history. Been winter cycling for 4 years. Have tried the following with the following results:
Pearl Izumi Lobsters WITH liners - good down to about 28-30. Just a matter of time until ice hooks after that
Heavy ski gloves - maybe better than most things. Good to a few degrees cooler than the lobsters
Heavy ski gloves with latex gloves inside - Sweaty gross hands, but this works pretty well. Just a GIANT pain if you have to do anything en route and don't want to go through multiple gloves. I can usually use them 2 or 3 times, but it's just a big messy pain.
Some misc. others that just suck. Why don't gloves seem to exist that are the cycling equivalent of the Lake cop boots? I have REALLY cold prone hands.
Does anyone have any good experiences?
I always post this response to this question, and everyone cheerfully ignores it. When it's really cold, I use pogies, moose mitts, overmitts, and they're magnificent! I first discovered them snowmobiling, and for bicycling, they are not to be believed. When it's really cold, I wear a liner glove, or no gloves at all. I got mine from Cabella's for about $20 and they're great.
I have had good results with felted woolen mittens (which I bought many years ago; they may be harder to find these days), covered by a wind/water proof mitten like this one:
The wool makes sure I can use them for a long time before they get to stinky. Yes, they limit movement somewhat, but I can still brake comfortably. And since I keep them as a pair (ie. the wool mitten resides inside the shell mitten at almost all times) it doesn't take any more time than putting a regular pair of gloves.
I have cold prone hands too.
You gotta go with mittens. No contest. I use Size XL burton mittens (with glove liners on super cold days), The extra roominess of the XL mittens makes it easier to use integrated shifters.
You don't have to go with fancy mittens though, even cheap mittens are going to work better that expensive gloves.
Thanks for the replies. I'm going to try some big overmitts. Haven't given that a shot yet. There's loads of good looking stuff at altrec.com. Hadn't come across that before. I got some outdoor research overmitts that look like they'll fit over Kraft lobster gloves. Will advise!
I love these liners. I got by last winter with just these and some fingerless gloves over them. When things dropped below 20, I switched to wearing these under the lobsters instead of the regular lobster liner. These things are comfy and cheap.
As far as the gloves, maybe add a hand warmer to the glove, some gloves have a built in spot
Our Gang Bicycle Club